Funny you should ask...I was just sorting out my smallie boxes

If you're looking for an alternative to the fly posted above for about half the cost,
people I trust tell me the Murdich Minnow is catching anything big that swims, including
smallies.

And you can get them here...
http://www.michiganstreamside.com/flies_streamers.htm (Mod, please yank this link, if not appropriate)
And, here's one I made and called the Silly Crayfish.

It's silly because of the silly legs, how easy it is to tie, and how many smallies it catches. The 1 1/4 inch holographic copper isn't cheap, but it sure grabs their attention.
Can't wait to get after 'em again!
Mike, thanks for starting this thread. I'd love to see other's "go to" flies for smallies.