Hey, that is a fish of a lifetime for that guy. I'm not going to bitch about him keeping a once-in-a-lifetime trophy like that. He caught a hell of a fish, and he's got every right to be proud of it. If he wants a skin mount, more power to him.
Now, if he was keeping and eating smallies over 4 lbs every chance he got, I'd have a BIG problem with it. (That would be exactly the same as my gripe with former member Tubakka and his crew for killing multiple trout over 20"). But until someone shows that he's doing that, I'm absolutely fine with him keeping one big fish.
Heck, I've got a couple skin-mount fish of my own from my younger days. If I caught a fish like that today, I'd turn it loose, but I completely understand if someone else makes a different choice.
Taking one trophy fish doesn't bother me a bit. I only get upset when it is taken to excess.
bd