IMO you cannot beat a good 3/4 finger windproof fleece glove. I have had a couple of cheap pairs and they worked great 1 was kenai the other reddington. I recently got the simms pair and they are friggin sweet. They also have a much longer wrist cuff than the others did. I can fish tailwaters all day long in the colorado winter weather wearing these and i stay warm.
a couple of weeks ago i put in two LOOOOONG days on the frying pan and the temps never broke 10 degrees. The simms gloves are killer. Wind blocking fleece is the crucial feature though, at least for me.